Double confirm, PM has no class

What with the second anniversary of LKY’s next week, below is the condolence letter that our PM sent to the widow of Fong Swee Suan earlier this year. It was a badly written letter.

PM should have not made the negative comments about how things would have been different (and implicitly, worse) if the Barisan Socialis had won: “Singapore’s history would have been utterly different if Mr Lim and Mr Fong had prevailed. Fortunately, they did not, as several of those who took their path recognised later, after the dust had settled.”

The PM should also have used the term “leftists” not “”pro-communists” in describing Fong and Lim Chin Seong etc. (But at least he didn’t call them “communists”.)

The letter then would have shown PM to be gracious, and a gentleman.

Still it’s a lot better than the letter he sent to the sons of JBJ on JBJ’s death (see below also).

The letter was extremely negative. Among other things it said JBJ “sought all means to demolish the PAP and our system of government”.

The letter was best not sent. While no fan of KJ, I can understand the anger he felt about it. He blogged on his anger.

Both letters show that PM has no sense of occasion. Blame his father (Mum was a lady, he was an educated thug)? After all his sister never lost her sense of entitlement (Example).

—————————————————

Dear Mdm Chen,

I am sorry to learn of the passing of your husband, Mr Fong Swee Suan. Mr Fong Swee Suan was a convenor of the People’s Action Party when it was formed in November 1954 and a member of its first Central Executive Committee. He and Mr Lim Chin Siong had joined Mr Lee Kuan Yew’s “Oxley Road” group earlier in the year to discuss the formation of a political party. Almost wholly English-educated, the non-communist group led by Mr Lee found in Mr Lim and Mr Fong a bridge to the Chinese-educated world – “a world teeming with vitality, dynamism and revolution,” as Mr Lee put it in his Battle for Merger talks, “a world in which the Communists had been working for decades with considerable success.”

The two sides, the non-communists and the pro-communists, joined forces to rid Singapore of the British colonialists, knowing full well that the real battle would come after the British left and Singaporeans had to decide who was to govern them.

Mr Fong and his pro-communist colleagues were arrested by the colonial authorities in October 1956 after a series of strikes and riots paralysed the island.

Mr Lee had to act as the detainees’ lawyer, and would visit them at St John’s Island every three or four weeks. I remember regularly taking a police boat together with my parents from the Master Attendant’s Pier at Collyer Quay to St John’s Island. My mother would bring along a pot of chicken curry and freshly baked bread for the detainees. It was a long walk from the jetty on the island to the house where they lived. I knew them by name, having met them when they came to Oxley Road, probably during election campaigns.

For me the trips to St John’s Island were Sunday outings. But for my father there was a serious purpose. My father spent hours trying to persuade the detainees of the folly of the Communist Party of Malaya’s policy. In the end, all the detainees signed a document, The Ends and Means of Socialism, which they themselves had drafted, setting out their support for the non-communist objectives of the PAP.

In 1959, Singapore attained self-government. The PAP won the general election, and formed the government. Mr Lim, Mr Fong and six other detainees were released from prison. Mr Lee and his senior colleagues were hopeful that all but Mr Lim were sincere in their declarations of support. He appointed the detainees as Political Secretaries in various ministries. Mr Fong went to the sensitive Ministry of Labour. In the end only one detainee, Mr Devan Nair, remained true in his pledge.

The inevitable parting of ways came in June 1961, over the question of Merger with Malaya to form the new Federation of Malaysia. The split was precipitated by the decision of the “Big Six” trade union leaders, including Mr Lim and Mr Fong, to oppose the PAP at a by-election in Anson. The pro-communists formed the Barisan Sosialis, with Mr Lim as its Secretary-General, and the Singapore Association of Trade Unions, with Mr Fong as its Secretary-General.

A ferocious battle for hearts and minds ensued. In the Referendum of September 1962, the option for merger recommended by the PAP won 70 per cent of the vote. Later in the general election of September 1963, the PAP was re-elected to office with 37 out of 51 seats, with the Barisan winning 13.

It is difficult for Singaporeans who did not live through the events to appreciate the passion of those times. This was a serious battle of ideas between two groups of people with diametrically opposed visions of our society. Singapore’s history would have been utterly different if Mr Lim and Mr Fong had prevailed. Fortunately, they did not, as several of those who took their path recognised later, after the dust had settled.

But it is important to realise that this was not a battle between good men and women on one side, and crooks and charlatans on the other. There were dedicated, disciplined, deeply courageous people on both sides. Indeed, Mr Lee and his colleagues liked and respected their opponents, admiring them for their simple lifestyles, selflessness and commitment. Mr Lee recalled in his obituary note on Mr Lim Chin Siong in February 1996 that his differences with Mr Lim were ideological and deep, but never personal. He would have said the same of Mr Fong.

Mr Fong and Mr Lee met for the last time in September 2009, in the chamber of the old Parliament House, where the PAP and Barisan Sosialis had crossed swords in those tumultuous years half a century earlier. The occasion was the book launch of “Men in White”, a history of the PAP. They shook hands warmly, and stood next to each other for a photograph.

As Mr Lee wrote, it was precisely because the PAP had such opponents, that he and his colleagues learnt “the meaning of dedication to a cause”:

“They were prepared to sacrifice everything for their cause, and many did. Some lost their lives in the jungle, many were banished to China. Because of the standards of dedication they set, we, the English-educated PAP leaders, had to set high standards of personal integrity and spartan lifestyles to withstand their political attacks. They were ruthless and thorough. We became as dedicated as they were in pursuing our political objectives.”

Please accept my sincere condolences.

Yours sincerely

Lee Hsien Loong

And

30 September 2008

Mr Kenneth Jeyaretnam
Mr Philip Jeyaretnam

Dear Kenneth and Philip Jeyaretnam

I was sad to learn that your father, Mr Joshua Benjamin Jeyaretnam, has passed away. Mr JB Jeyaretnam was a Member of Parliament for Anson constituency from 1981 till 1986, and a Non-Constituency Member of Parliament from 1997 till 2001. He used to engage in heated debates in the House. Perhaps it was because he and the PAP never saw eye to eye on any major political issue and he sought by all means to demolish the PAP and our system of government. Unfortunately, this helped neither to build up a constructive opposition nor our Parliamentary tradition. Nevertheless, one had to respect Mr JB Jeyaretnam’s dogged tenacity to be active in politics at his age.

However, our differences were not personal. In 1993, one of you (Kenneth) wrote to Mr Goh Chok Tong, who was then Prime Minister, to say that you found employers in Singapore reluctant to offer you a job, and your only explanation was that the employers felt the authorities would not welcome your employment because of your name. Mr Goh replied with a letter which could be shown to prospective employers, to say that the government did not hold anything against you, and that employers should evaluate you fairly on your own merits, like any other candidate, because Singapore needed every talented person that it could find. Mr Goh had previously made the same point to your brother Philip, whom he had invited to lunch. I am therefore happy that both of you have established yourselves in Singapore.

Please accept my deepest condolences.

Yours sincerely
Lee Hsien Loong

 

 

Cynical Investor

Cynical Investor blogs at Thoughts of a Cynical Investor.

 

 

Sponsored Content

16 Responses to “Double confirm, PM has no class”

  • hhh:

    A class person won’t pursue AHPETC relentlessly and changing the acts to fix the innocent.

    A class person won’t have his sister write those things about him.

    A class person won’t hurt locals with all those pro FT policies.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • PAP has the mandate:

    It does not matter, I get to see LKY the old geezer died and was suffering in his last years where he basically cannot stand on this two feet.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • LIONS:

    Not only no class,it is. LOWLY.
    I alao boh class but i am not lowly.

    How to lead like that?
    No wonder many sgs are sufferring.
    This bloke is not just a lousy leader,he is a BADVleader.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Alan:

    Long Ge is a Bad Ass ..a Ba Ba black sheep …Yes Sir Yes Sir ..3 bags fools…a Humpty Dumpty had a great fall…a Sick man of Sinkyland ..a noboLee shouting at Cheena to follow law in SCS…a emperor without clothes & a joker or clown in the world circus…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Heart of glass:

    PM=longwinded n ill tempered.
    Always taking the ‘long n winding road…
    Like that ND speech. Going all thro sg’ s history from day one…till he pengsan.
    … an old broken record..no body wants to hear anymo.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Lye Khuen Way:

    Well, it is his brand of Condolence Letters! Don’t know if his late parents had taught him any common courtesy, especially when someone is grieving.
    Pathetic behavior unbecoming of a Prime Minister.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • C'est la vie:


    This PM holds only one view; HIS !!!
    How would this “kind/type/mindset” benefit any country/republic/state ……….. EVER !!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Bapak:

    This is worse than AY.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • kick sand in dead man's face:

    Letters of condolence for Lee Hsien Loong, what will they be like????

    how will chee soon juan, kenneth j, fong’s family write theirs when the time has come for this sick, insensitive, arrogant bas***d son of LKY?

    many people (still alive) who were contemporaries of LKY had been forgiving and did not write anything bad when he died. they knew lky as a nasty cruel and cunning bas***d but they did not write anything bad when lky died.

    You know the pioneer gen had this to say about LKY. LKY is a person who will cross the bridge and will then destroy the bridge so that people who had helped him will be left stranded.. A departed relative told me.

    Now Lee Hsien Loong the son of LKY is on record in SG history as a person who kicks sand and mud at a dead man’s face

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Rats can't vomit:

    About as convincing as a Prime Minister queueing for chicken wings in public to show that he is down to earth after his bodyguards swept the area for threats.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • N.Jungne:

    Got lah, DISHONORABLE is a class of its own.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • BuyMeBakKutTeh:

    Agree agree… 70% of sinkies also no class, no brain and no balls… thus voted for their same breed!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Merobok:

    The purpose of the so-called” condolence” letter to the wife of Fong is not to show respect but to exonerate the PAP including his father from their actions during the 60′s!
    He had no opportunity to explain or rebut what Thum JP had provided in his research into S’pore’s early history and no other lap dogs dared to do it because the evidence provided in London was real stark!
    So, use the condolence letter to it’s maximum but in reality, is a piece of poor writing and thinking!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • rukidding:

    Still water runs deep !

    Looks are deceiving !

    Actions and talks are most “revealing ” !

    Which sister or brother of yours would “wash your dirty linen” infront of public ?….much less from someone coming from the “elitist” class ?

    Of course his Sister is telling the truth !

    Confirm this guy is a “spoilt brat”,….a typical “small boy behaviour “…..typical ….”sissy”, with plenty of “traits” of a typical low class woman’s kind of “siow chi” ( small minded non magnimous ) behaviour !

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • d "winners" write History . ..:

    C'est la vie:

    This PM holds only one view; HIS !!! . . .

    -

    Jack Nicholson – he “can’t handle the truth”. . . :(

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • The Other Hard Truths:

    In Chinese, this type of character is called “下三流鼠辈”

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
Member Services
Members LoginSelf-ClassifiedsSelf-Support
Sponsored Advertisement





Search On TR Emeritus
Sponsored Advertisement



Most Recent Comments
  • flabbergasted: Seow Leow: All the PAP silly billies try to muddy up the issue. The real matter is : LKY has...
  • 亜李爸爸: Let us all put our efforts to get the PM to be accountable to this serious wrong doing, a case just as serious...
  • PAP cocksuker: When we go for our BMT in the army we are made to swear allegiance to the President and the...
  • blueview: Tharman, President Tony Tan is keeping his mouth SHUT and ENJOYING HIS PENSION AND HIS MILLIONS! Can you do...
  • blueview: It is also called KARMA!
  • Amos humiliate L*L and PAP: Cisco Kid: Cabinet needs to explain clearly their reasons for wanting to preserve...
  • LHY vs. LHL: Even an ordinary man can read the simple language in a written will, let alone SG’s great man LKY...
  • Bebe: What kind of a elder brother would not trust his own siblings? Instead of protecting his own siblings and...
  • A Nation Of Dumb Parrots: These are all yes men. All interviewed and recruited the same way, drank the same tea, sang...
  • Who Stole My HDB?: Need more on La wrence Wong: Good idea. Need to know if Lawrence Wong is also...
  • All In The Familee: Someone did say: “It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his...
  • Oldtimer: Pretty pointless in keeping the house if no one can enter it. Unless of course, a law is passed saying it...
  • Twelve Years NS Deferment: flabbergasted: tony tan, where are you? why and for what are you keeping quiet? everybody...
  • l'ingenieur: There are two camps in SG right now. Those that think that slathering on the makeup can bring on the...
  • Snake-Catcher: Dear Sweet-Talker Indranee Rajah, Very shameful leh, You know or not? Please don’t speak like a...
  • Total Stupidity Inc.®: Indranee Rajah’s analysis of the will is far more subtle and complicated than a...
  • Bapak: It has already happened in Termasick my friend that’s why they are losing money. To the D1 & D2...
  • opposition dude: The house can be demolished, why would there be any law that says a house cannot be demolished? So...
  • BuyMeBakKutTeh: WL n HY… thank you both for speaking up. Be it private or public. Both of u have opened a big...
  • BBC: Its over Folks: China PLA involved in wars in the 21st Century… hahaha. CCP should award you a medal...
  • New Egg Yoke: Even if Christ, Buddha or Allah were to appear in Holy Trinity and backs LWL and LHY, Pinky and...
  • TWL: The use of a ministerial committee is absolutely inappropriate and an abuse of power. trying to resolve a family...
  • Remember: She cleaned up as a daughter in law, but arranged to loan the items as PMO point of contact. Does anyone...
  • Bapak: The second point was that the Oxley Road house is no longer a private matter, as it is closely bound up in the...
Announcement
Support TR Emeritus
Support TR Emeritus:
Other Amount:
Advertisement
Advertisement
Free Classifieds
  • shree Travels and Transport Company.

    shree Travels and Transport C/o. We are providing ...
    [Read more]

  • DJ Hardy (The Spin Machine)

    We provide professional D.J?s, sound lightings and...
    [Read more]

Readers Statistic
Latest Statistic