PAP-NTUC relationship erodes workers’ rights?

I refer to the article “PAP draws NTUC closer amid disruption” (Straits Times, Nov 25).

It states that “The symbiotic relationship between the People’s Action Party (PAP) and the unions is deepening.

The National Trades Union Congress (NTUC) on Tuesday said PAP ministers and office-holders will take on additional advisory roles within various NTUC arms, such as its unit for freelancers and self-employed people.

All PAP MPs, where possible, will also advise not just unions – as they already do now – but professional bodies under the NTUC as well.

The announcement came two days after PAP secretary-general Lee Hsien Loong reiterated the importance of his party’s symbiotic relationship with NTUC at the PAP convention on Sunday.

He said: “Over the decades, the PAP and the labour movement stood together through many difficult times… Because we stayed together, the country thrived, and people’s lives improved.”

NTUC sent one of the largest delegations in history to the PAP’s annual get-together this year. At 240-strong, it is 10 times the delegation size in most years. An NTUC leader also spoke at the convention.

There are three reasons the PAP and NTUC might want to forge more extensive ties at this juncture.”

As to “First, workers are likely to be affected by economic disruption in the short to medium term. The strengthened links may be a way for the two to brace themselves for difficult times ahead and to ensure that adversity does not divide them” – let’s review what the very close PAP-NTUC relationship has given to workers.

… so many low-wage workers

… very low per hour wage of as little as $6

… very little of the jobs growth in the recent years went to Singaporeans

… increasing (real) unemployment rate which is masked by the conversion of foreign workers to permanent residents  (PRs) and new citizens

.. rising umder-employment translating  into freelance, contract and part-time jobs

… horrendous working conditions, such as the overtime exemption for security guards to work up to 95 hours of overtime a month

With regard to “When the PAP split in 1961, the left-leaning faction departed to form a new party – Barisan Sosialis. The majority of unions that had supported the PAP up to that point switched allegiance to the Barisan Sosialis and formed a new umbrella group called the Singapore Association of Trade Unions (Satu).

The smaller pro-PAP labour movement then formed NTUC in the same year. Over time, NTUC won over some unions. But the decisive moment was the 1963 General Election. The PAP won 37 out of 51 seats. Barisan Sosialis got 13 seats. After that election, Satu was refused registration, and many unions eventually decided to join NTUC” – if we had an alternative union to fight for workers’ rights – do you think the outcomes for workers may be better now?

In respect  of “Today’s NTUC may seem unassailable, with its chief represented in Cabinet, strong unions across all sectors, and a stable of successful social enterprises providing affordable insurance, groceries, childcare and healthcare services, among others. But its birth amid bitter factional rivalry is part of the NTUC’s DNA. Its history explains the strong institutional ties between it and the ruling party.

The PAP-NTUC symbiotic relationship prevents rival parties from co-opting the unions. If the PAP and NTUC serve the interests of a broad swathe of workers, they will also prevent the rise of a rival labour movement that might want to work with an opposition party” – isn’t this a clear and obvious conflict of interest when the head of the unions is always a cabinet minister?

Are there any countries in the world with such an arrangement?

As to “The latest move to include professional bodies – which have traditionally been non-partisan – is a new development. It remains to be seen how this would be implemented – for example, whether a group that prefers not to have a PAP MP advising it can choose to be excluded from the arrangement” – this may be clear evidence that we are not a democratic country.

With regard to “Mr Lee is not the first to stress the need to understand PAP’s and NTUC’s history. Past NTUC leaders have said that each new generation of unionists needs to appreciate anew the value in the relationship.

Why might young unionists not fully recognise the benefits of the bond with the PAP? They may see a loss of agency by the unions, as a result of the tie-up.

The NTUC secretary-general has conventionally been appointed to the Cabinet. While this gives the unions a bigger say than it would otherwise have in the formulation of national policies, it may also constrain NTUC’s ability to act with greater autonomy, because it has to consider the views of other PAP ministers – if it wants to continue to reap the gains of the partnership” – the statistical outcomes for workers may clearly indicate the failure of such a system to protect worker’s rights.


Leong Sze Hian



Sponsored Content

6 Responses to “PAP-NTUC relationship erodes workers’ rights?”

  • oxygen:

    PAPpy WANTS TO CO-OPT PROFESSIONAL BODIES so that it can influence policy directions within these professional organisations?

    Soon, they will be set on the blood loyalty test of obeying PAPpys command and control order of when to fart and what political fragrance to fart.

    ALREADY THE LEGAL PROFESSION ACT has shut down the lawyer profession’s mouth from commenting publicly about many of the unlawful acts of PAPpys – from CPF matters to unelected President.

    Next in line will be the accounting professional bodies which might one day needs to look at creative government accounting including hollow log accounting as might be relevant to the deception of Pioneer Generation Package.

    China is doing the same thing to foreign invested entities in China – they want to force foreign business to form party-line grassroot representation in their organisational hierarchy – ostensibly to watch out for subversive anti-state cells in the employ of foreign enterprise. The German confederation of businesses in China have already warned that it might move out all its investment in China if Xi JiPing gang insist on their ways. Foreign enterprises SUSPECT these proposed insertions of its party-preferred political cadres is a tool by which Chinese government insert commercial spies into western technology inside China.

    GD Star Rating
  • nathan:

    PAP-NTUC-Manpower-Employers’Federation act in cahoots to suppress human and worker’s right to their own agendas.

    NTUC means Never Trust Union Congress. NTUC is the worst enemy of rank and file workers. Their first and last priority is always to serve their political master the PAP. NTUC is a fake union and will always remain so as long as the PAP is in total control of this cuntry.

    The Tripartite working arrangement is nothing but an unholy trinity between the PAP, NTUC and the Employer’s Fed to prosper at the workers’ well-being and expense.

    GD Star Rating
  • LIONS:

    Symbiotic relationship$$$$?!!!
    Wtf,they treat us like sheep.

    As for the older jobless PMETs,it is sad to see so many good sgporeans kena screwed of their jobs.
    Now,getting older n needing more medicare,the govt still want to scheme to fafk us more by raising G$T?

    GD Star Rating
  • Simply Not Right!:

    MPs should not get involved in Unions/Workers’ matters.

    They are voted into Parliament by their constituents and they must ‘work’ for their constituents and look after their welfare and well being.

    Some MPs are already absenting themselves from Parliament Sittings and if they get involved in Unions/Workers’ matters, Parliament will be even more empty than before!

    MP must focus on their basic roles and not be ‘a Jack of all Trades and Master of none!’

    GD Star Rating
  • Dou Ying = Wu Ying:

    Did we learn about this in JC? It’s called tripartism.

    GD Star Rating
  • MPs will Tow The Line...:

    You think MPs got the balls to backup the Unions and Workers?

    They will be more concerned about their own ‘rice bowl’ first!

    Let’s not bluff ourselves!

    GD Star Rating

Leave a Reply

 characters available

Member Services
Members LoginSelf-ClassifiedsSelf-Support
Sponsored Advertisement
Search On TR Emeritus
Sponsored Advertisement

Most Recent Comments
  • Dont be so vile: He’s a disgrace. After all the hardwork put in by the good people going out of their way to...
  • Bye bye: No love lost. Go lah, go… Sure to ‘step down due to health reasons’.. actuallt PAP will...
  • 鸟龙的人: 陈大婶: 就是说九九年租期 ? 干嘛要付产业税呢 ? 因为"利光要"样样都要嘛! 在外国是免税的,除了出租才須付所得税。
  • oxygen: DR TAN CHENG BOCK IS NOT WRONG when he said – that Singapore’s political system has created an...
  • Haigen Daiz: The first en-bloc owners are already paid. Money in bank already. So no problem even if Chinese...
  • Purpose of HDB: Purpose of HDB is just to make sure Singaporeans will defend Singapore, so a leased flat is branded...
  • oxygen: @ Ong PC You made en bloc deals like a walk in the park. If the buyer/developer is a top Singapore listed...
  • bgkl: A liar to the grave…call himself a “Singapore watcher”…for whose benefit? May his ashes...
  • doggie: He would retire before next GE. gong gong sinkies will be pleased and continue to vote pee n pee. After next...
  • doggie: Yes. 69.9% daft sinkies will kpkb but they were too afraid of the unknown so they will keep voting for the...
  • TUCK WAN: 69% Dafts will disagree. I am 100% agree.
  • S$8 Bypass Man Blame God: When he runs out of excuses, he unwisely blame God for the lightning striking the MRT train...
  • The Rot Start From The Top: This country is ruled by a regime comprises of politicians that is no different from...
  • C'est la vie: ***** In truth, not only are they daft; do include what further completes, the undeniable dna of all...
  • Smart Nation, Unwise Leaders: What the use of being a smart nation with all the latest IT gadgets and software when...
  • Bystander: IF you wanna get rid of military culture at GLCs, then you have to get rid of those at the Cabinet level...
  • Rabble-rouser: No mistakes, no human failings – no possibility of success! Only by making repeated mistakes...
Support TR Emeritus
Support TR Emeritus:
Other Amount:
TRE Classifieds
  • Best South Indian Restaurant

    Mutton Gravy is the favorite weekday dinner item f...
    [Read more]

  • Sample of a Free Ad

    . This ia a sample of how a Free Ad (without imag...
    [Read more]

  • fish gravy in singapore

    Fish Head Curry is the one of the most popular- Si...
    [Read more]


    More Information Are You In Need Of A Private Or ...
    [Read more]

Readers Statistic
Latest Statistic