Statement on the Extension of the Criminal Law (Temporary Provisions) Act (CLTPA) for another five years

We are strongly opposed to the extension of the Criminal Law (Temporary Provisions) Act by another five years and expansion of its scope.

Similar to the Internal Security Act, the CLTPA allows indefinite detention without trial under the hand of the minister with the consent of the public prosecutor. Under the amendment bill, anyone who is arrested and imprisoned will also be deprived of his right to pursue judicial review before the High Court as the Minister’s decision is final. We take strong objection to such a draconian law as it can be easily misused.

The CLTPA was enacted in 1955 when Singapore was partially independent. It was meant as a temporary measure “to strengthen the law against those who seek to overthrow the lawfully elected Government by violence, or who seek to subvert the minds of the people by intimidation, away from genuine democracy and constitutional advance to self-government, to the rule of fear and to ultimate Communist domination.” (Chief Secretary, Mr W A C Goode).

At the time of its enactment Mr Goode said:

“These measures, we think, are necessary during a period of immaturity in understanding and practising democracy to safeguard us from the dangers that beset us on the path to maturity. We hope, therefore, that they will no longer be needed after that period and, accordingly, all these various matters have been put together into this one Bill which, by sub-clause 2 of clause 1, is to remain in force for a period of only three years. As the title of the Bill indicates, these are temporary additions to our criminal laws.” (Legislative Assembly debates Sept 21, 1955).

It is regrettable that under the PAP government, Singapore has remained a politically immature country for the past 52 years. The government continues to rely on this draconian law to govern and indeed, over the years has deemed it fit to extend its power over ordinary crimes which are already taken care of by the arsenal of legislation existing today.

The CLTPA has serious consequences for the people of Singapore. The amendment bill has even more serious implications for law-abiding citizens. From its original intent of dealing with alleged communists, its application has been extended to criminal activities of secret societies, unlicensed moneylending and drug trafficking after it was no longer possible to use the communist threat as a reason.

Under the amendment bill, the application of the law will extend to human trafficking, robbery with firearms, murder, gang rape, kidnapping, organised crimes (under the Organised Crime Act 2015) and attempt to carry out, abet or being a party to all the aforesaid named crimes (see Fourth Schedule). For each of these crimes, there are already existing laws such as the Penal Code, Kidnapping Act, Public Order Act, Corrosive and Explosive Substances and Offensive Weapons Act.

Section 30 of the CLPTA grants the minister and public prosecutor the right to order detentions if they are “satisfied that it is necessary that the person be detained in the interests of public security, peace and good order”. We believe in the separation of powers as guaranteed by the Constitution of the Republic of Singapore. The power to order detentions should only be exercised by our judiciary after a full and open trial. Our judges should also have the power to conduct judicial reviews of abuse of power by the executive.

We are utterly dismayed that our government, despite its decades of experience in governing Singapore, has deemed it necessary to retain this unjust temporary law and indeed, make it even more oppressive.

We call upon all Members of Parliament to oppose this amendment bill and to propose that the Criminal Law (Temporary Provisions) Act should not be extended at the expiry of its life on 20 October 2019. Singapore today has more than sufficient laws to take care of all offences under the CLTPA. Judicial powers should only be exercised by our judiciary and not the executive.

We urge Singaporeans to scrutinise the proceedings of parliament and demand that parliamentary debates be live-streamed so that everyone can know what is happening in parliament starting from the debate of this totally unwarranted amendment bill.


Joint statement issued by three Human Rights Non-government organisations, Function 8, Think Centre and Community Action Network.




Sponsored Content

4 Responses to “Statement on the Extension of the Criminal Law (Temporary Provisions) Act (CLTPA) for another five years”

  • Are you serious?:

    Quote: “We call upon all Members of Parliament to oppose this amendment bill and to propose that the Criminal Law (Temporary Provisions) Act should not be extended at the expiry of its life on 20 October 2019.” Unquote.

    Call upon all Members of Parliament to oppose? You can’t be serious!

    GD Star Rating
    a WordPress rating system
  • Dictatorship:

    One step away from total control!

    GD Star Rating
    a WordPress rating system
  • dolphin81:

    The extension of the Criminal Law (Temporary Provisions) Act is something which for now, I support the PAP ruling class. The CLTP was an effective tool against the organised underworld which in turn thanks to GCT’s foreign talent globalisation had managed to somewhat reconstitute itself after practically destroyed by pre-1990 LKY.

    Considering the timidity of Sinkies at the workplace when faced against FTs, does anyone think obedient Sinkies will really cooperate with police against organised crime FTs in legal due process? This is part of the reason why FTs have become more arrogant, including towards the police.

    Hopefully, the police itself will not become too pro-FT.

    GD Star Rating
    a WordPress rating system
  • HarderTruths:

    There is already total control. This just makes it look legit to international courts and human rights groups.

    It appears the pappies are planning something BIG. Can you feel it? All new laws, president from own party lines, change in economic policies. There is something tat pappies are trying to hide but when it comes out they hope to have the resources and manpower to control the people.

    It may be the harbinger of a monetary collapse or seizing absolute power in the next election.

    Done in slow steps o the people do not notice. Next stage may be cashless financial system where they control all your money. If that happens then the facade of a elected government is over and the truth of a police state will be complete.

    Keep watching for more such signs. They are everywhere.

    GD Star Rating
    a WordPress rating system

Leave a Reply

 characters available

Member Services
Members LoginSelf-ClassifiedsSelf-Support
Sponsored Advertisement
Search On TR Emeritus
Sponsored Advertisement
Most Recent Comments
  • opposition dude: So this means that the election will be next year or 2020 before GST is upon us in 2021. By then we...
  • they dine at Din Tai Fung: how much nourishment is there: What or how much nourishment is there...
  • Well up to 70% now.: Well , up to 70% now.
  • opposition dude: The handing over has been bungled, just like how the MRT is always giving problems, the HDB lifts...
  • PAP is BEST: PAP best one, increase tax is good means Swiss Standard of Living is coming. Last time, PM Goh GST 3%...
  • N.Jungne: Heng Ah Keat has already said he has no benchmark and too troublesome, so this is a “Gasak Buta” budget....
  • Give more lah: Should give at least $1000 instead of $300 to be meaningful.
  • N.Jungne: HarderTruths: We cannot solve our problems with the same thinking we used when we created them. Albert...
  • oxygen: OF COURSE IT IS FARKING WAYANG, 2017 budget gave up to $300 PER HOUSEHOLD as a special one-off relief for...
  • pap selected INDIAN president: The carbon tax will encourage businesses to take measures to reduce carbon...
  • pap selected INDIAN president: pap Ljs and pap Cbs please listen. your MFing group think is truly disastrous. carbon...
  • Nonsensical budget: Increasing rates everywhere , then they cunningly give us rebates n angpows ..for what? Makes no...
Support TR Emeritus
Support TR Emeritus:
Other Amount:
Visitors Statistic
Latest Statistic