Everything you think you know about Singapore is wrong

Gordon Brown

On a Sunday morning in the UK on a weekly BBC TV show about politics a British Conservative politician came out with an astounding figure for Singapore’s trade. He was intending to reassure British viewers that leaving Europe wouldn’t harm their economy. Look, he was suggesting, Singapore is also a tiny island nation and their trade expanded exponentially when they left the Malaysian Federation and now they’re so rich! We can just copy those cheerful oriental fellows.

The only problem with his argument is that his figures were off by a factor of 100 and everything else he believes about Singapore is a myth. On air the politician Iain Duncan Smith said our total trade grew by US$50 trillion when in fact it’s less than half a trillion. Neither the Labour Lord Mandelson brought in for balance, nor the BBC anchor Marr, challenged this figure which shows how much they know. (Unfortunately for the UK they have democratically elected politicians rather than the self-selected meritocracy that we enjoy in our dictatorship and surprisingly they seem to be just as thick as the ones the Familee select to run their fiefdom).

‘Leavers’ as they are known in the UK, seem to believe that Singapore left the Federation with Malaya of its own accord in order to take back control or some such nonsense and that this independence is key to our wealth. If only they knew about LKY’s tears and how much he wanted to be part of a larger union. They can read more here.

So what is the key to our wealth? Well at this point I can hear you all screaming, “what wealth?”. Exactly. Singapore is held up by leavers as a successful model of a low-regulation, low-tax regime. Some simple facts that will astound the Brits are that our Government owns 80% of the land and most of the largest public companies. Our Prime Minister who is LKY’s son and no its not Nepotism if you have a double first from Cambridge, is chair of our first SWF, GIC and he appointed his wife to run Temasek, our second SWF which controls the majority of Singapore’s biggest companies. Again , its not nepotism if your wife etc etc. 90% of our population live in public housing (HDB) with a 99 year lease expiry date and can be made to relocate if a profitable development opportunity comes along for the Government. This I know is something that wouldn’t suit the “My home is my castle” Brits. Most Brits who’ve been in Singapore have never been in an HDB unit and so spread the myth that we all live in portered condos with swimming pools and gyms and servants. As many of us know from previous experience many Brits cannot even stomach our crowded public transport and the ripe aroma of sweaty humanity in the tropics(remember Anton Casey?).

So what about our GDP? Like Ireland, a large part of our GDP is driven by MNC tax-avoidance strategies so very high levels of GDP per capita do not translate into median incomes. Our seemingly miraculous levels of GDP growth are mostly due to the inputs of cheap foreign labour. Paul Krugman pointed this out in the 1990s when he wrote about “The Myth of Asia’s Miracle”. In fact output per hour worked is lower than most developed countries and much lower than other global cities to which Singapore should rightly be compared. Our GDP figures simply do not bear scrutiny.

Labour leavers who want to Remain hate only one thing more than Brexit and that’s Tory Austerity. With all this state ownership and control we must be a Socialist paradise right? No, because we have no Welfare State and our government has always said (and for Brits who don’t know we’ve only ever had one government in more than 50 years) that it will never allow welfare to take hold. LKY famously said that Singaporeans must not be allowed to develop a dependence mentality and that the spurs must be kept to our sides through mass immigration to keep us competitive. And so our country runs a heartless regime of self reliance. Not married? You can’t buy an HDB flat. elderly parents? You are obliged to move them in with you, they can sleep in the corridors. Sick? Don’t get sick you won’t be able to afford the medication (In fact the PM, himself a cancer survivor, said the best way to avoid high medical bills was to stay healthy) . Unemployed? That’s a shame, move in with your relatives. Those British people would be rioting on the streets if they had to endure even a tenth of the daily austerity that makes our lives so harsh. We would feel like millionaires if we had a tenth of their benefits and security.

The single sweetest irony in all of these anti immigrant Leavers citing Singapore as a model for Brexit is that 40% of our workforce is foreign labour, most of whom come from very poor countries and in the absence of a minimum wage earn as little as £1 an hour. I’m convinced “immigration” is a major reason if not the reason why UK voters voted for Brexit. You see the Labour Government under Tony Blair in 2004 thought it could emulate the secret of Singapore’s success and create a miracle of fast economic growth by allowing workers from Eastern European countries that had joined the EU like Poland and later Rumania to work in the UK without any restrictions other than those already applying to UK workers.

Not surprisingly to an economist, although it took the UK by surprise, there was an immediate influx of some 3 million Poles because Polish wages were about a quarter of UK levels. Labour thought this would be acceptable to UK voters because all the newly admitted workers were white and they naively thought that racism was mostly about skin colour. As a result of the influx of migrant workers Labour lost the 2010 election. The PM contesting that election was Gordon Brown. His famous “bigot woman incident” is cited as a key contributor to that election loss and by the way proof that the root cause of racism is economic competition not skin colour. The phenomenon of white on white racism seemed to have eluded the Labour Party of the time. The video is here but in brief Gordon Brown left his microphone on in his car after a walkabout and was recorded calling a woman he’d spoken to a bigot because she was complaining about high levels of immigration from Eastern Europe). The Tory’s David Cameron similarly underestimated white on white racism because bigotry and anti immigrant sentiment again led the UK to vote for Brexit against all expectations in 2016. Singapore has seen about 2.5 million immigrants added to our population since the 1990s. Migrants make up 40% of our population yet levels of just 5% immigration have brought governments down in the UK and sparked a constitutional crisis.

Brexiteers are deluding themselves and others by claiming that all the UK has to do is follow the Singapore model to achieve undreamt of levels of economic prosperity. Or that separating themselves from a trade federation is a wise move. First UK voters, and particularly the industrial heartlands and working classes, voted for Brexit because they did not want a Singapore-style low-wage non-existent labour protection type of economy, Secondly, emulating Singapore will not bring prosperity to the bulk of the population but wages on a par with Kuala Lumpur. ( A UBS survey in 2011 comparing purchasing power between global cities put Singapore workers on a par with those in Kuala Lumpur. After this was pointed out and discussed in Singapore’s Parliament with much Government embarrassment and feeble excuses, the PAP Government got UBS to drop Singapore from the survey in future.)

Singapore cannot fail to prosper because of its incomparable strategic location at the crossroads of world trade as well as its fine natural harbour. This fact was recognised as early as the fifteenth century by the Portuguese when they seized Malacca in an effort to control the eponymous Straits and grab the spice trade from the Venetians. Most of Singapore’s growth post-1965 is fully explained by the growth in world trade. Whatever prosperity we do have has nothing whatsoever to do with trade tariffs or tax regimes or independence. It has everything to do with immigration, with austerity and with the pure luck of our location. The UK as a whole enjoys no such advantage so it is a waste of time trying to emulate our model which in any case would be deeply unattractive to any free people.



Kenneth Jeyaretnam

* The author blogs at https://kenjeyaretnam.com/.




Sponsored Content

4 Responses to “Everything you think you know about Singapore is wrong”

  • patriot of Temesak:

    A pity Ken is NOT in Parliament instead of the Barking Dogs that Barks on COMMAND…Stay COOL!!! Ken, your day will COME!!! The TRUTH will shine and DARKNESS & EVIL will fade away!!!

    GD Star Rating
  • Waiting for the end of PAP:

    Want more intelligent n thrilling parliament sessions?
    Vote in more opp parties in, like KJ, CHEE JS, LIM TEAN, and the of course WP SYLVIA LIM.
    instead of switching off the tv whenever those “snake oil salesmen/women” get up to speak, with the likes of CHEE, SYLVIA, KJ etc , we’d be rooted to our seats watching. I can only hope most of the 69% had woken up by now.

    GD Star Rating
  • Britons are degenerating:

    Who has evidence of exchange between the two PMs and the weeper exhorting Sinkies to stand up while he nursed his disgrace publicky should send copies to these nfi Brits. A British woman tourist was heard talking to a old Singaporean couple in a food court in a shopping mall that she was surprise to find out that the brits have been fed with fake news when she was here just not even a week. Wonder how much shits PAPplps have been feeding the Brits but they must be degenerating as they should realize how PAP has been importing their worst scumbags in hordes just to feel how great they r even the Britons are brownosing up to them.

    Good grief. The plagiarist of Shanghai pork soup from the tap and window smokers to use them as dinner jokes for their atas dinner reception should have alerted their sense. Good grief.

    GD Star Rating
  • pap selected INDIAN president:

    Britons are degenerating:

    Good grief. The plagiarist of Shanghai pork soup from the tap and window smokers to use them as dinner jokes for their atas dinner reception should have alerted their sense. Good grief.

    very well said, bro. that is why Singapore is not wanted in OBOR despite what pap clown’s visit to Mr Xi in 2017 to beg for forgiveness from Mr Xi.

    najib who does not speak Chinese, joko who does not speak Chinese, duterte who does not speak Chinese, all welcome to China. departed pap evil scum lky clown prince who speaks from the wrong hole NOT welcome to China.

    clap clap clap. we are not pap yes men yes women. we won’t tell departed pap evil scum lky clown prince everything is fine with China. rather. we tell him if he continues Singapore is doomed.

    departed pap evil scum lky clown prince thought China is like all his yes men yes women who would clap clap when he talks nonsense. NO. China is a world power. not any pap yes man or pap yes woman. China says go fly kite clown. and rightly so. GO FLY KITE.

    GD Star Rating

Leave a Reply

 characters available

Member Services
Members LoginSelf-ClassifiedsSelf-Support
Sponsored Advertisement
Search On TR Emeritus
Sponsored Advertisement
Most Recent Comments
  • Tom lee: Well the Dis*&# Son wants to show fist to US by going ahead with TPP. What nonsense TPP without US and...
  • MarBowling: Think D Trump hasn’t forget what Mai Hum has passed negative remarks about him bf he was elected as the...
  • patriot of Temesak: The DIFFERENCE??? one is a MAN who walks like a Dragon…the other is a SHIM neither she or...
  • Lye Khuen Way: Hear, Hear! Agree with Mr Tan that what our PM had announced so far are just outdated model. We would...
  • patriot of Temesak: PM Lee is trying to IDENTIFY himself with the Billionaires after all he belongs to a Dynasty that...
  • patriot of Temesak: Father & Son are BEHOLDEN to the SWAMP headed by Kissinger…Killer of UNBORN BABIES and...
  • HarderTruths: The USA is a warmonger and only looks after itself. $G is a tool nothing more. $G has stupidos like LHL...
  • Kiuk, Great Woman: Wow. She’s impressive. Like Ong TC, dare to ask how much is in the reserve. For OTC, the...
  • Char Chong Fake: opposition dude: And PAP wants to set up a wayang committee to look into fake news? Ironic is...
  • Eviil be gone: Ad hominem is an attack directly at a person’s character . It’s a method equivalent to...
  • Eviil be gone: He did not die from liver? So lucky rich man. Is liver disease a rich man good life disease due to...
  • What is there sto defend?: The assumption is that NS men have good reasons to defend the country. But what is there...
  • 'Fake' Chairman?: For A Parliamentary Committee on Fake News? Got Moral Standing or not? Be a Gentleman and stand up...
Support TR Emeritus
Support TR Emeritus:
Other Amount:
Visitors Statistic
Latest Statistic