While Norway insists on transparency, our Familee-managed SWFs prefer the fishing in muddy waters

Yesterday the Financial Times reported that Norway’s Finance Ministry had forbidden its sovereign wealth fund (SWF) from investing in private equity. In the article the Norwegian Finance Minister said that “Private equity does not fit the model we have chosen for the fund. The greatest challenge is openness, information we can share with the public.” 

The article also quotes Ludovic Phalippou, a finance professor at the University of Oxford’s Saïd Business School and author of Private Equity Laid Bare:

The private equity model is a difficult one for the Norwegians to get their head around. It is hard to feel comfortable to invest via funds which can basically do whatever they want in terms of fees and expenses. They may have become more transparent but whatever information they provide is not easy to process and incentives remain misaligned in most funds.”

Since 2009 I have questioned our need for not just one, but two, SWFs. The standard economic justification for an SWF is where you have an exhaustible resource, like oil, and want to ensure that as it is used up it is replaced by capital, either financial assets or infrastructure. Norway is the perfect example. In the Norwegian case there was also a desire to avoid the curse of mineral wealth, which is an overvalued exchange rate and a squeeze on manufacturing which becomes uncompetitive. This is something that happened to both the Netherlands (with natural gas) and the UK (with North Sea oil) in the 1970s and 1980s.

This justification does not apply to Singapore where our SWFs have been built up by a deliberate mercantilist policy of excess saving achieved by holding down wages and consumption through CPF and budget surpluses. However if you were going to have an SWF then the Norwegian model is the one Singapore should emulate. Norway’s Pension Fund is run explicitly for the benefit of the people, is totally transparent (you can see its real-time valuation at http://www.nbim.no/) and is essentially an index fund owning on average 1.4% of every listed global company.

As I have said, much of Temasek’s supposed superior returns come from the injection of underpriced state assets, like SingTel and Singapore Airlines, at inception which then produced spectacular returns when they were listed. Temasek and GIC do not release much detail about their returns or valuation policies but it is doubtful that they have outperformed the Norwegian Pension Fund on a transparent and equivalent basis.

In July 2017 Temasek’s head of strategy, Michael Buchanan, said in an interview with Bloomberg News, that Temasek was planning to buy more unlisted assets and that “We have some advantages in the private space.” It is easy to see why unlisted assets and private equity would be attractive to Ho Ching and GIC. Valuations are opaque and there is more than a suspicion of collusion between the leading private equity firms to keep prices high for the purposes of marking their books. This was demonstrated recently when Softbank bought a stake in Uber at a valuation of US$48 billion a 30% discount from the previous funding round valuation of US$68 billion. At the same time Softbank led a fresh investment round of US$1.25 billion at the old higher valuation with no other purpose than to allow existing shareholders to continue to price their holdings at the older inflated price. Clearly losses and a multitude of other sins can be covered up.

Additionally as Phalippou is quoted as saying above, the non-transparent fee structure may allow the managements of Temasek and GIC to siphon off some of the funds or to co-invest their own money on preferential terms with inside information not available to ordinary Singaporeans. Ho Ching’s remuneration remains a state secret that Tharman said is not in the public interest to disclose which strongly suggests that her earnings amount to billions of dollars over the years. These bonuses become much easier to justify if valuations become easier to manipulate.

Unlike Norway, Singapore’s SWF’s are not accountable to Parliament but only to Lee Hsien Loong (Chairman of GIC) and his wife. The WP have never made any attempt to push for greater accountability. The words of Khaw Boon Wan, uttered in Parliament in February 2015 during a debate on WP’s management of the Aljunied-Hougang-Punggol Town Council, “Where the water is murky, it’s easier to fish. Opacity creates opportunity for crooks to make money.” I noted the exquisite irony when I wrote about it then in “The Problem with Husbands and Wives in the WP, in the Ruling Family, in Our Reserves. I also pointed out the irony of Hri Kumar saying that it’s not that the AGO did not note any criminal activity, but that the AGO does not know if there was because of the state of AHPTC’s records. Similarly we have no idea whether there is anything fishy going on at Temasek or GIC because of the deliberate lack of transparency. Investing in unlisted assets and private equity adds another welcome and easy to exploit layer of opacity for their managers.

Norwegian waters, whether full of oil or not, are clearly much more transparent than the murky waters Ho Ching, Lee Hsien Loong and the managements of GIC and Temasek like to fish in. Clearly, as long as the PAP maintain their hegemony in our travesty of a Parliament while an Opposition not worthy of the name colludes in keeping them in power,  we are never going to know just how good the fishing is.


Kenneth Jeyaretnam

* The author blogs at https://kenjeyaretnam.com/.



Sponsored Content

11 Responses to “While Norway insists on transparency, our Familee-managed SWFs prefer the fishing in muddy waters”

  • rukidding:

    “Opens” for “Opportunity” for Corruption …Oops. sorry , I mean “errors and mistake”….which are hard to “track and trace or follow the trail”.

    Well….hasn’t these kind of “habits” been going On for someime ardy ?

    What to do when they ardy know they have 70% Dafts “trapped” by them.

    GD Star Rating
    a WordPress rating system
  • Chris Bong:

    My only fear for young Singaporeans is that there may not be much reserves left when they grow up or when PAP is ousted.

    GD Star Rating
    a WordPress rating system
  • Bapak:

    Any brave ex-Norwegian migrated here and become an idiot?

    Any ex-Sinkies migrated to Norway? Clever!

    GD Star Rating
    a WordPress rating system
  • wah!! Angmo Tua Kee !!!:

    Norway’s Finance Ministry had forbidden its sovereign wealth fund (SWF) from investing in private equity ….. said that “Private equity does not fit the model we have chosen for the fund. The greatest challenge is openness, information we can share with the public.

    GD Star Rating
    a WordPress rating system
  • Our hard earned monies:

    We should be hunting talents from Norway Sovereign Funds, of which we can get value, transparency and accountability as well as spending much less $$$ in management’s fees.

    GD Star Rating
    a WordPress rating system
  • C'est la vie:

    Retrospectively speaking, in whose interest is it, if not the people’s, to continue to conceal Ho Ching’s remuneration.

    Do the people, whose money it is that she has her hands on, not have the right to know or is it a right that has been summarily removed by the SGov, along with their rights to free expression, transparency and accountability.

    Oh SG, oh SG, how the f**k did you get yourself into such a shi*hole position !!!

    GD Star Rating
    a WordPress rating system
  • LIONS:

    Norweigens believe in meritocracy;70 pct of sgs subscribe to MEDIOCRITY.

    GD Star Rating
    a WordPress rating system
  • patriot of Temesak:

    When CORRUPTION is LEEgal nothing left but sucking your thumb, The Matriarch & Patriarch are ashes in a URN…unless like The Phoenix they will Rise from their ashes or Reincarnate DESTROY the DYNASTY before it DESTROYs the Republic of Singapore…The Owl had HOOT and the Patriarch went to its hole…the Owl HOOT again TWICE to be exact one as a Warning with no response to Repent & Repay…and the other is a TIMELINE of no longer than 2020!!!

    GD Star Rating
    a WordPress rating system
  • Exposed:

    The only way for Temasek Holding to be exposed is via external forces such as the infamous 1MBD case.

    GD Star Rating
    a WordPress rating system
  • HarderTruths:

    Norway is a white man’s first world country who do not cheat each other.

    $G is full of asian of all types from third world who backstab each other for every small thing. All racist asians who hate each other and give their own kind jobs.

    How to compare the two? Like comparing cake and shit.

    GD Star Rating
    a WordPress rating system
  • John Maynard Keynes says:

    “Capitalism is the astounding belief that the most wickedest of men will do the most wickedest of things for the greatest good of everyone …. Long run is a misleading guide to current affairs. In the long run we are all dead.”

    GD Star Rating
    a WordPress rating system

Leave a Reply

 characters available

Member Services
Members LoginSelf-ClassifiedsSelf-Support
Sponsored Advertisement
Search On TR Emeritus
Sponsored Advertisement

Most Recent Comments
  • never voted pap: someone told us in Aljunied coffee shop pap PA chairman very angry with pap IB CI for not able to...
  • never voted pap: we never trusted pap. never. when singtel tv braodcast Al Jazeera, we paid for the broadcast. we are...
  • LIONS: When they subsidise F1,got ask about salary or not?
  • PAP.Guarantee.Win.GE2020: Dear Oxygen, You claim to be doing well in OZ, so please go back OZ and stop instigating...
  • l'ingenieur: Chris Bong: A vote for PAP, means you are selling out your future and that of your children. This...
  • Haigen-diaz: PM Lee is still following the path of his father’s legacy but through an intense program of kakistocracy...
  • world shift to Authoritarian: The world is moving towards conservatism and authoritarianism. This is thanks to screw...
  • Ferrari Saw CB: Is SMRT stand for SMART? STUPID or smart?
  • Rabble-rouser: : I went to SIM Lim recently, a shock of my life, almost 90% are foreigners. Where have the locals...
  • Thor long: This how washing machine works.
  • 3 crabs: 3 crabs salary is very high, equivalent or higher than CEO salaries in small companies. A VP in a GLC may...
Support TR Emeritus
Support TR Emeritus:
Other Amount:
TRE Classifieds
  • Sample of a Premium 4 Ad

    . This ia a sample of how a Premium 4 Ad (can upl...
    [Read more]

  • Oregon Scientific

    Oregon Scientific was established in Portland, O...
    [Read more]

  • Parasol Inn Chiang Mai Hotel

    Parasol Inn by Compass Hospitality is decorated ...
    [Read more]

  • Neck Relax

    Tired of neck pain? Immediate relief, wherever you...
    [Read more]